Johnson theorized that labeling children as stutterers only served to. The monster study received this negative title due to the unethical. The tudor study tudors 1939 thesis, titled an experimental study of the effect of evaluative labeling on speech fluency, was designed to test several assumptions of the diagnosogenic theory. An experimental study of the effect of evaluative labeling of speech fluency.
It was labeled the monster study by some of the persons who were associated with the stuttering research program at the university of iowa during the. The monster study was a stuttering experiment performed on 22 orphan children in iowa in 1939. The 25 most influential psychological experiments in history. Half of the children received positive speech therapy, praising the fluency of their speech, and the other half, negative speech therapy.
Dreamstime in 1939, speech pathologists at the university of iowa set out to prove their theory that stuttering was a learned behavior caused by a. In 1939 mary tudor, a graduate student at the university of iowa, and her faculty advisor, speech expert wendell johnson. Specifically, tudor and johnson investigated the influence of applying the labels stuttering and normal. The study showed that the negative reinforcement made the stuttering worse than before. As i come of age and find happiness in joining the ranks of israel, the knowledge. The monster study was a stuttering experiment performed on 22 orphan children in davenport, iowa in 1939. In 1939 mary tudor, a graduate student at the university of iowa, and her faculty advisor, speech expert wendell johnson, set out to prove stuttering.
March 16, 2003 the stuttering doctors monster study by gretchen reynolds wendell johnson was a tall, knobby 20yearold farm boy when he arrived at the university of iowa in iowa city to study english in 1926. As a result of the study, children with no stuttering problem were left with selfesteem issues, and none of the actual stutterers were helped. It was conducted by wendell johnson at the university of iowa. The case has not only thrown a spotlight on an experiment some participants bitterly call the monster study, it has also illustrated the way research ethics have evolved over the years. Wendell johnson was a speech pathologist, and he himself suffered from a stutter. Ma master of arts thesis, state university of iowa, 1939. The class president and valedictorian of his tiny high school in. First it had extremely shaky practically nonexistent ethical standards. Cloward and ohlin 1961 argue that shaw and mckay 1939, 1942 failed to. The socalled monster study on childrens stuttering qualifies for this series on weird psychology on three grounds. Graduate student mary tudor conducted the experiment under johnsons supervision. The findings of this study and the events that occurred subsequent to its completion have never been published.
Second its results were never published for fear it would be likened to experiments carried out by the nazis rothwell, 2003. The monster study of 1939 10 outrageous experiments. An experimental study of the effect of evaluative labeling. The problem of ordinary monsters and the holocausta. Five orphans who, as participants in a 1939 monster study, were subjected to harassment in an attempt to get them to stutter have settled a lawsuit with the. Theremin, the monster study, roid rage 19 dec 2012 7. At the university of iowa in 1939, wendell johnson and his team hoped to discover the cause of stuttering by attempting to. Tudors 1939 thesis, titled an experimental study of the effect of evaluative labeling on speech fluency, was designed to test several assumptions of the diag.
March 16, 2003 the stuttering doctors monster study. The results of a covered up, 1939 childrens experiment demonstrates why ahrp calls for greater caution and mandatory safeguards in research involving childreneven noninvasive research studies may cause children harm for life. Jane elliotts famous experiment was inspired by the assassination of dr. Pdf recent years have seen an upsurge of attention paid to street gangs as. The 1939 experiment has come to be known as the monster study because of its methods and the theory researchers set out to prove that.
694 1009 1538 274 1010 608 772 1250 1514 498 558 1155 440 699 834 570 1426 1455 1364 289 1525 390 1003 926 600 942 12 1228 189 54 1125 940 1059 261 1189 996 372 127 294 520 470 1280 405